Transcript of Voice of Community kick-off chat

Topic: VOC process defining chat
Date: January 8th, 2009
Time: 3:00 PM Central European Time
Duration: 1 hour
Conversation: netbeans
Chat Client: NetBeans Developer Collaboration module
  • Tushar Joshi (India)
  • Michel Graciano (Brazil)
  • Melongo Annabel (USA)
  • Jiri Kovalsky (Czech Republic)

  • 2:59:53hmichel joined the conversation
    2:59:56amelongo joined the conversation
    2:59:57Jiri Kovalsky joined the conversation
    3:00:07hmichel hi jiri
    3:00:17Jiri Kovalsky Hello guys!
    3:00:22amelongo Hi
    3:00:36Jiri Kovalsky Hm, looks like Tushar didn't make it.
    3:00:53tusharvjoshi joined the conversation
    3:00:53Jiri Kovalsky Oh, he is online!
    3:00:59Jiri Kovalsky Hello Tushar!
    3:01:05tusharvjoshi Hello All
    3:01:12amelongo Hello Tushar
    3:01:17Jiri Kovalsky I am very happy to meet you online today during our kick-off chat dedicated to defining the VOC initiative in more detail.
    3:01:17hmichel Hello again
    3:01:32Jiri Kovalsky Let me share with you the agenda.
    3:01:56Jiri Kovalsky Does everyone see it?
    3:02:07amelongo yes I see it.
    3:02:19tusharvjoshi I can
    3:02:21hmichel yes
    3:02:31Jiri Kovalsky Great, how are you, by the way?
    3:02:55amelongo I fine and excited...
    3:03:24hmichel Really cool, just enjoying the vacation now
    3:03:31tusharvjoshi I am good, curious to work on the next steps
    3:03:52hmichel and yo
    3:04:07hmichel and you?
    3:04:14Jiri Kovalsky I hope you are fine and looking forward to the brand new process you will have a unique opportunity to shape!
    3:04:42Jiri Kovalsky I am good as well. Very relaxed after the Christmas break.
    3:05:00Jiri Kovalsky So, let's pick the first item in the agenda.
    3:05:13tusharvjoshi ok
    3:05:51Jiri Kovalsky It is period of service. I would like to hear your opinions on the time you would like to serve as VOC captains.
    3:06:10Jiri Kovalsky What is your preference? 1 year or just a half a year?
    3:06:11tusharvjoshi Shall we align the period of service with the release schedule of NetBeans?
    3:06:26amelongo I will opt for one year
    3:06:44Jiri Kovalsky Well, this is tricky. Length of NetBeans releases might vary.
    3:07:12Jiri Kovalsky Some take 6 months, some 1+ year just like NetBeans 6.0.
    3:07:39hmichel I really like the Tushar idea
    3:08:04Jiri Kovalsky Which means one release?
    3:08:05hmichel but jiri is right, there is no fixed period for nb releases
    3:08:25tusharvjoshi Can we know the tentative date of NetBeans 7.0
    3:08:43tusharvjoshi If it is 6 months from now then it shall be 6 months period of service
    3:09:44hmichel I understand that 'one release' is the next release of IDE, both major or minor releases
    3:09:52Jiri Kovalsky Yes, we aim to have FCS out there in mid June.
    3:10:20tusharvjoshi I am open for the 1 year period also
    3:10:30amelongo Why should we bind the voc Captains work with a Netbeans release?
    3:10:42tusharvjoshi this way we will be working past NetBeans 7.0 also for some time
    3:11:11tusharvjoshi I thought that way after reading the description of the VOC concept for getting priority bugs fixed first by reading the community voice
    3:12:51hmichel I understand that captains should try to integrate community wishes on the IDE, so, changing the captains probably will refresh the priorities, and I understand this changes are better after a release is closed.
    3:12:59Jiri Kovalsky OK, if we take 1 year then it would mean calendar year. And I would organize another call for captains in December 2009.
    3:13:31hmichel btw, I had no problem with both periods
    3:13:33tusharvjoshi This also sounds good and convinient
    3:13:46tusharvjoshi Jan to Dec
    3:13:54hmichel yes
    3:13:58amelongo that's fine for me
    3:14:03Jiri Kovalsky Yep. Look like we have an agreement.
    3:14:40Jiri Kovalsky Now hard part. What if some of you want to resign or will not have time for the VOC?
    3:15:06Jiri Kovalsky I think resignation is okay anytime, right?
    3:15:34tusharvjoshi Yes I also think resignation is Ok, there may be surcumstances beyond ones control
    3:16:03hmichel yes, it is true
    3:16:32amelongo You don't have someone on the waiting list? for example the people who suscribe to be captain but who were not chosen... Personally, I will make it to the end unless something really bad happens...
    3:16:44tusharvjoshi So if one of us withdraws, can we call for another person to join and take the place in between?
    3:17:19tusharvjoshi Yes, it is also a good idea to keep the fourth shortlisted person in mind
    3:17:35Jiri Kovalsky And what if the latter happens? Would it be okay to replace some VOC captain who becames unresponsive for some reason?
    3:18:34Jiri Kovalsky I have more candidates of course. I just want to know if replacement is possible after certain time and under what circumstances.
    3:18:46tusharvjoshi In My Opinion it is ok, the project shlould be active through all the participants
    3:19:00hmichel I just don't see any problem about replacement
    3:19:33Jiri Kovalsky OK, so what do you consider a maximum inactivity period?
    3:19:39hmichel we know that problem can happen for anyone, and the show must go on
    3:20:02hmichel jiri, there is similar rules for netcat?
    3:20:27Jiri Kovalsky No. NetCAT was based on CAT points system and not time.
    3:20:46amelongo I would suggest, you get personal phone numbers and if a participant is inactive, try to first email and then call and if after those two attempts fail, we give the captain a period of one month to be responsive and if we still don't hear from him/her, then you can make a replacement.
    3:21:17Jiri Kovalsky I was also thinking about 1 month.
    3:21:25tusharvjoshi I think inactivity of 15 or 30  days is enough to gauge that the member has become inactive,
    3:21:46tusharvjoshi 1 month it is then
    3:21:56Jiri Kovalsky I personally think that 2 weeks is too strict.
    3:22:33hmichel i agree, 1 month is ok, at least because sometimes we need to travel, and one or 2 weeks is really short
    3:23:12Jiri Kovalsky Great, so are you Tushar and Michel comfortable with providing me your phone numbers?
    3:23:18tusharvjoshi I am also ok with 1 month, and we will always notify the list about our absense for some period while travelling
    3:23:43hmichel no problems for me
    3:23:50Jiri Kovalsky Mine is +420 *** *** ***
    3:24:01tusharvjoshi Tushar Joshi, +91-***-***-**** it is all over the Net already
    3:24:14amelongo do you have mine, Jiri?
    3:24:29Jiri Kovalsky Don't worry, I will replace the numbers with *** in the transcript.
    3:24:45Jiri Kovalsky Not yet.
    3:25:13amelongo My phone is 001-***-***-****
    3:25:29hmichel +55 ** ********
    3:25:41Jiri Kovalsky Great, thank you gentlemen!
    3:26:04Jiri Kovalsky Now, let's move to the next item in the agenda: list moderation.
    3:27:10Jiri Kovalsky Would somebody of you be willing to help me with moderating the VOC list? We can expect many feedback soon that will require moderation.
    3:27:44Jiri Kovalsky Or we can open the list for anyone just like it is with nbusers@ for example.
    3:28:00amelongo what tasks does it require?
    3:28:53Jiri Kovalsky Each post from a non-subscriber generates an moderation request e-mail. You open that e-mail, verify that it is not a spam and approve it.
    3:29:03tusharvjoshi do you feel the list can get abused or spammed by making it open like nbusers?
    3:29:29Jiri Kovalsky 10 seconds per 1 request. But there will hopefully be tens of e-mails soon.
    3:30:01Jiri Kovalsky No, but I setup the list as private so that only we 4 can post there freely.
    3:30:46tusharvjoshi Ok so that means the list is unmoderated for us 4, and moderated for the world
    3:31:12tusharvjoshi In that case I feel people from different time zones can better manage the moderation requests
    3:31:35Jiri Kovalsky If somebody contributes there often I can put him/her among allowed posters which will not generate the moderation requests.
    3:31:56Jiri Kovalsky Yes, that's why I wanted to distribute the moderation.
    3:32:25tusharvjoshi I am open to help in moderation
    3:32:50Jiri Kovalsky We would need somebody from America and Asia as I can cover Europe and Africa timezones.
    3:33:51tusharvjoshi I am from Asia, India for most of the times, I travel from USA to NZ but those will be one or two weeks
    3:34:23amelongo I'm living in America. I can do that.
    3:34:26Jiri Kovalsky That's great.
    3:34:27hmichel left the conversation
    3:34:41Jiri Kovalsky Looks like we lost Michel.
    3:35:37amelongo I think he has connection issues...
    3:36:05tusharvjoshi yes may be and in that case he may connect in a short while again
    3:36:40Jiri Kovalsky OK, so Melongo covers America, Tushar has Asia and I will be responsible for Europe and Africa.
    3:37:01amelongo Great
    3:37:22tusharvjoshi Please note my gtalk id as well "tusharvjoshi" for such disconnections
    3:37:41Jiri Kovalsky OK, thanks.
    3:38:17Jiri Kovalsky Cool, so what about meetings? In my humble opinion we don't need to meet weekly.
    3:38:45Jiri Kovalsky What is your preference? Once in 2 or 3 weeks?
    3:38:58tusharvjoshi Yes we can meet bi-weekly and if something comes up which is urgent we can call for a meeting
    3:39:11amelongo I think so too. I has to wake-up really early today... bi-weekly will be ok... and preferably during the week-end
    3:39:57Jiri Kovalsky What is your local time Melongo?
    3:39:58tusharvjoshi yes and what about the preferred time?
    3:40:17amelongo right now is 8:40 am
    3:40:22tusharvjoshi I am GMT+5.30
    3:40:56Jiri Kovalsky So it's 9:10 p.m. there?
    3:41:12tusharvjoshi 8.10 pm here
    3:41:49Jiri Kovalsky Oh, yes. I am not in GMT. Had too little coffee today ...
    3:42:35Jiri Kovalsky So what is your preference guys? Melongo wants to have it 1 hour later while Tushar wants the opposite?
    3:43:13tusharvjoshi I am ok with any time
    3:43:18amelongo Why don't we do it during the week-end? That's why it doesn't matter anymore for me...
    3:43:35tusharvjoshi Let us hear from Melongo first
    3:43:55Jiri Kovalsky Hm, weekend is problematic for me because I have 3 kids and 1 wife who want me to be with them. :-)
    3:44:36amelongo what about fridays?
    3:44:38Jiri Kovalsky But if we can't find suitable time during working days I will have to somehow manage it.
    3:45:17Jiri Kovalsky In my opinion we should first try to find best time, not?
    3:45:35amelongo The reason it's problematic for me is that generally during this time, I'm working. But today I'm not.
    3:46:21Jiri Kovalsky I see and what time is best on Friday?
    3:46:33tusharvjoshi So is 9 or 9.30 a good time for you Melongo?
    3:46:56amelongo What about 6pm on fridays?
    3:47:29Jiri Kovalsky What timezone?
    3:48:33amelongo I really don't know the time zone. It will be 6pm Central Time.
    3:48:59Jiri Kovalsky It think it would be too late for Tushar.
    3:49:12tusharvjoshi it is 4am for me
    3:49:29Jiri Kovalsky Oh! What about 4:00 p.m. CET
    3:49:46Jiri Kovalsky How are Fridays different for you Melongo?
    3:50:15tusharvjoshi 4pm CET means just like today but one hour late
    3:50:27Jiri Kovalsky Yes.
    3:50:47amelongo On friday, it's really relax at the office, so I can be participating in the chat without being summoned...
    3:51:44Jiri Kovalsky I see. So what do say to my proposal of Fridays at 4:00 p.m. CET (9:00 a.m. your time)?
    3:52:18amelongo It's fine. Fridays CET
    3:52:33tusharvjoshi Fine with me also
    3:52:39Jiri Kovalsky Great! Let's hope this will be acceptable for Michel as well!
    3:53:05Jiri Kovalsky Now, do you have problems with publishing transcripts of our conversations?
    3:53:20amelongo I think so. He lives in Brazil and the time there might not be that different from mine. Let's hope the time will work for him as well.
    3:53:45Jiri Kovalsky I agree. What about transcripts?
    3:53:54amelongo I don't have any problem with publishing transcripts.
    3:54:07Jiri Kovalsky OK, Tushar?
    3:54:11tusharvjoshi Same with me, no issues to make them public
    3:54:49Jiri Kovalsky Remember, everyone of us has a Veto right so you will be able to deny publishing in any case.
    3:55:27Jiri Kovalsky I see that we have already done 5 out of 6 items on the agenda.
    3:55:40amelongo Great.
    3:55:55Jiri Kovalsky So, let's move to the last one: do you prefer deviding functionality&channels by individuals?
    3:56:26Jiri Kovalsky Like one will mostly read blogs, another one will monitor nbusers ...
    3:56:37amelongo I think it would be nice.
    3:56:58tusharvjoshi We can choose main areas, and still keep working on all the areas
    3:57:19Jiri Kovalsky Or somebody will focus on NetBeans Core features, another person will cover infrastructure or J2EE...
    3:57:41Jiri Kovalsky Frankly I would rather be realistic.
    3:58:15amelongo Is it a way you can list the different functionalities and channels?
    3:59:23Jiri Kovalsky Well, basically I was thinking about channels as
    4:00:12Jiri Kovalsky And areas divided only to NetBeans Platform, J2EE support and J2ME support. Any other suggestion?
    4:01:20tusharvjoshi I have preference of blogs and mailing list as channel, and core and platform area
    4:02:11amelongo I would go for J2EE and J2ME support then
    4:02:29Jiri Kovalsky BTW, Michel wrote to me that he was facing an energy outage in his city so he can't join us today.
    4:02:50Jiri Kovalsky Great, and J2SE will be hopefully covered by Michel.
    4:03:04Jiri Kovalsky What channels do you prefer Melongo?
    4:03:31amelongo What other channels do you have?
    4:04:05Jiri Kovalsky In total we have mailing list, netbeans chat, blogs, forums (DZone, ServerSide)
    4:04:05tusharvjoshi they are theserverside and dzone forums
    4:04:25Jiri Kovalsky Yes, and maybe also this chat.
    4:05:29amelongo I would like chat, blogs and forums
    4:05:44Jiri Kovalsky Cool, thanks!
    4:05:59Jiri Kovalsky We are little over time but did what was planned for today.
    4:06:19Jiri Kovalsky Do you have any questions for me before we leave the room?
    4:06:52tusharvjoshi I think we can continue discussion on the mailing list
    4:07:00amelongo I was just wondering how are people going to send suggestions to us if the mailing list is private?
    4:07:02Jiri Kovalsky That's right.
    4:07:11tusharvjoshi I have no specific questions here
    4:07:52Jiri Kovalsky They can send it to the list but we will have to approve their posts. That's all.
    4:08:18amelongo Ok. Then I don't have any question anymore. Thanks.
    4:08:19Jiri Kovalsky And the archive is accessible from web.
    4:08:30tusharvjoshi ok
    4:08:32Jiri Kovalsky So are we done for today?
    4:08:53amelongo Yes. It was my pleasure meeting with you all.
    4:08:58tusharvjoshi Yes, thanks for this meeting Jiri (Is is Jiri or Jirka?)
    4:09:24Jiri Kovalsky Mine too! Well, Jiri is formal. You can call me Jirka!
    4:10:03Jiri Kovalsky Next meeting is scheduled for 1/23! Have a nice time guys!
    4:10:12amelongo Thanks. You to

    [ Homepage | List archive | Next chat ]

    $Date: 2009/11/02 14:13:06 $ GMT

    Project Features

    About this Project

    QA was started in November 2009, is owned by Jiří Kovalský, and has 97 members.
    By use of this website, you agree to the NetBeans Policies and Terms of Use (revision 20160708.bf2ac18). © 2014, Oracle Corporation and/or its affiliates. Sponsored by Oracle logo
    Please Confirm